knittingknots (knittingknots) wrote,
knittingknots
knittingknots

  • Mood:

Odd contemplation....

So here I am, bopping around some of the science/technology/economic/political forums that I like to read, some on a daily basis.

Then a thought struck me:  If you are worried about something (global warming, peak oil, the end of the world as we know it, whatever - pro or denier, counting on your POV) and you hang around sites filled with like-minded people, how do you keep yourself and your group from reinforcing that shared viewpoint to the point where you go beyond the real data, where it starts to function as belief instead of knowledge?

This may be a pretty hard-wired human tendency.  We tend to hang with people who share a similar POV, and we keep our group identity by reinforcing each other through repetitions of our core beliefs, which may or may not be fact based; and often we label those who don't share our beliefs with nasty labels - I've seen it in fandom groups, as people orient around favored pairings or canon v. non-canon or slash v. non-slash, computer operating systems (Mac vs. PC always starts religious wars!), various niches in science (start looking at some of the hot wars in archaeology for a start, but there are other areas where it went or is still going hot).  I won't even talk about high school groups, religion or politics.

How do we avoid it?  This zero-sum, Us vs. Them, self-reinforcing polarization has caused us a lot of grief as a species.  But it gets even worse when one has to make rational decisions about tricky scientific and economic issues.  How do we keep belief out of the reality of what the data says?  Is it even possible?

Tags: the human condition
Subscribe

  • Drabble: Fatigue

    A little piece of IK. This will almost certainly end up in some form in TEA, but the idea hit me now, so I wrote it. It's their first experience…

  • Drabble: Midnight Silk

    A dash of midnight postmanga fluff, cause I wanted to. Midnight Silk InuYasha lay in bed next to his sleeping wife, not yet able to fall asleep.…

  • Drabble: First Things First

    So here I am, outlining a serious epic fantasy type story, and making a little progress against my normal inertia, when Pink pops up and says,…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 3 comments